Chenedy Wiles, 27, poses for a portrait at her house on Wednesday in Chicago. Wiles took a 23andMe check over the summer time and acquired her leads to September. Whereas she finds the info breach regarding, “a lot of our knowledge is already on the market,” she mentioned.
Taylor Glascock for NPR
conceal caption
toggle caption
Taylor Glascock for NPR
Final month, Chenedy Wiles lastly acquired round to it.
The 27-year-old touring nurse spit right into a tube and mailed it to 23andMe, the place the genetic testing firm’s lab examined her DNA and generated a glimpse of her ancestry.
“One of many causes I made a decision to get the check is that as an African American, it’s quite common for our heritage to get misplaced,” mentioned Wiles, who lives in Chicago.
As soon as her outcomes arrived within the mail, it revealed that she was practically 40% Nigerian. “Which was thrilling and funky to see,” she mentioned, “as a result of I at all times thought I had cousins who had been from West Africa.”
After that, 23andMe contacted her frequently about signing up for add-on companies, or to have kin take the check, however she wasn’t .
The one-and-done nature of Wiles’ expertise is indicative of a core enterprise downside with the as soon as high-flying biotech firm that’s now teetering getting ready to collapse. Wiles and plenty of of 23andMe’s 15 million different prospects by no means returned. They paid as soon as for a saliva equipment, then moved on.
Shares of 23andMe are actually price pennies. The corporate’s valuation has plummeted 99% from its $6 billion peak shortly after the corporate went public in 2021.
As 23andMe struggles for survival, prospects like Wiles have one urgent query: What’s the firm’s plan for all the info it has collected because it was based in 2006?
“I completely assume this must be clarified,” Wiles mentioned. “The corporate has undergone so many modifications and a lot turmoil that they want to determine what they’re doing as an organization. However in relation to my genetic knowledge, I actually wish to know what they plan on doing.”
What is going to 23andMe do with the DNA knowledge of 15 million prospects?
Andy Kill, a spokesperson for 23andMe, wouldn’t touch upon what the corporate would possibly do with its trove of genetic knowledge past normal pronouncements about its dedication to privateness. “For our prospects, our focus continues to be on transparency and selection over how they need their knowledge to be managed,” he mentioned.
When signing up for the service, about 80% of 23andMe’s prospects have opted in to having their genetic knowledge analyzed for medical analysis. “This fee has held regular for a few years,” Kill added.
The corporate has an settlement with pharmaceutical large GlaxoSmithKline, or GSK, that permits the drugmaker to faucet the tech firm’s buyer knowledge to develop new therapies for illness.
Anya Prince, a legislation professor on the College of Iowa’s Faculty of Regulation who focuses on genetic privateness, mentioned these fearful about their delicate DNA info might not understand simply how few federal protections exist.
For example, the Well being Insurance coverage Portability and Accountability Act, also called HIPAA, doesn’t apply to 23andMe since it’s a firm outdoors of the well being care realm.
“HIPAA doesn’t shield knowledge that’s held by direct-to-consumer firms like 23andMe,” she mentioned.
Though DNA knowledge has no federal safeguards, some states, like California and Florida, do give shoppers rights over their genetic info.
“If prospects are actually fearful, they might ask for his or her samples to be withdrawn from these databases underneath these legal guidelines,” mentioned Prince.
In keeping with the corporate, all of its genetic knowledge is anonymized, that means there is no such thing as a manner for GSK, or another third occasion, to attach the pattern to an actual individual. That, nevertheless, may make it practically unattainable for a buyer to renege on their choice to permit researchers to entry their DNA knowledge.
“I could not go to GSK and say, ‘Hey, my pattern was given to you — I need that taken out — if it was anonymized, proper? As a result of they don’t seem to be going to re-identify it simply to drag it out of the database,” Prince mentioned.
23andme says it is not going to let legislation enforcement search its database
Vera Eidelman, a workers lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union who focuses on privateness and know-how coverage, mentioned the patchwork of state legal guidelines governing DNA knowledge makes the generic knowledge of thousands and thousands probably weak to being offered off, and even mined by legislation enforcement.
“Having to depend on a non-public firm’s phrases of service or backside line to guard that sort of info is troubling — notably given the extent of curiosity we have seen from authorities actors in accessing such info throughout felony investigations,” Eidelman mentioned.
She factors to how investigators used a family tree web site to establish the person generally known as the Golden State Killer, and the way police homed in on an Idaho homicide suspect by turning to comparable databases of genetic profiles.
“This has occurred with out folks’s information, a lot much less their categorical consent,” Eidelman mentioned.
Neither case relied on 23andMe, and spokesperson Kill mentioned the corporate doesn’t enable legislation enforcement to look its database.
The corporate has, nevertheless, obtained subpoenas to entry its genetic info.
In keeping with 23andMe’s transparency report, authorities have sought genetic knowledge on 15 people since 2015, however the firm has resisted the requests and by no means produced knowledge for investigators.
“We deal with legislation enforcement inquiries, resembling a legitimate subpoena or courtroom order, with the utmost seriousness. We use all authorized measures to withstand any and all requests with a purpose to shield our prospects’ privateness,” Kill mentioned.
Board resigns after cut up with CEO Wojcicki
Two latest developments have added much more gas to privateness issues: Final yr, the corporate was hit with a serious knowledge breach that it mentioned affected 6.9 million buyer accounts, together with about 14,000 who had their passwords stolen.
Anne Wojcicki, founder and CEO of 23andMe, and Marcus Wallenberg communicate at an occasion throughout Prince Daniel’s Fellowship entrepreneurial journey in San Francisco in 2022.
Kimberly White/Getty Pictures/Getty Pictures North America
conceal caption
toggle caption
Kimberly White/Getty Pictures/Getty Pictures North America
And earlier this month, 23andMe’s board of administrators and the corporate’s CEO had a dramatic falling-out. After Chief Government Anne Wojcicki proposed a plan to buy the entire firm’s excellent shares herself and take the corporate non-public, the board pushed again, and, ultimately, resigned en masse.
In a public letter to Wojcicki, the board members mentioned whereas they nonetheless again the corporate’s mission, they can’t assist Wojcicki. They wrote that that they had been ready months for her to element a plan for the corporate’s future, nevertheless it has but to reach, which “leads us to imagine no such proposal is forthcoming.”
In a September submitting to monetary regulators, Wojcicki wrote: “I stay dedicated to our prospects’ privateness and pledge,” that means the corporate’s guidelines requiring consent for DNA for use for analysis would stay in place, in addition to permitting prospects to delete their knowledge. Wojcicki added that she is now not contemplating gives to purchase the corporate after beforehand saying she was.
Some analysts predict that 23andMe may exit of enterprise by subsequent yr, barring a chapter continuing that might probably restructure the corporate.
And for patrons like Wiles, the wait is a bit of unnerving. She opted out of permitting her knowledge to be studied. “One thing about that causes me a little bit of pause,” she mentioned.
However given the corporate’s rickety standing, she mentioned, “I hope my genetic knowledge isn’t misused in a roundabout way. I do marvel what precisely they intend to do with all of it.”
