In June 2022, the person identified on-line as “Conservative Anthony” drove me to a few what he calls migrant “scorching spots,” by the border in El Paso, Texas. He’s made a profession out of migrant searching; he stalks and confronts individuals he suspects of being migrants whereas livestreaming the encounters on his web site, Border Community Information, and plenty of social-media accounts. He has given border excursions to Republican lawmakers, together with Lauren Boebert and Marjorie Taylor Greene, and was captured in January 6 movies chanting “Our home!” because the mob left the Capitol.
Conservative Anthony’s actual identify is Pedro Antonio Aguero. He was born and raised in El Paso, a baby of Mexican immigrants. Like many Latinos in South Texas, he grew up a Democrat. However Aguero now believes that the Democratic Celebration is permitting an “invasion” throughout the southern border. And the recognition of his content material—his followers complete greater than 100,000 throughout completely different social-media platforms—means that he’s not alone.
Aguero is an excessive instance of a broader phenomenon. Many Latinos have shifted to the suitable on immigration in recent times, warming as much as the concepts of constructing a wall, shutting down the southern border, and even conducting mass deportations. Help for Donald Trump amongst Latino voters grew by 8 share factors from the 2016 to the 2020 presidential election, and polls counsel that Trump continues to make inroads with Latino voters main as much as the 2024 election. Anti-immigrant sentiment usually comes from a spot of worry. Folks could also be afraid that immigrants will take one thing from them: jobs, alternatives, or, maybe extra profoundly, a way of their very own nationwide and cultural identification. However I’ve come to grasp that anti-immigrant Latinos aren’t simply afraid of loss. Not like white People, in addition they have one thing to show: that they, too, belong in America. “I don’t lock the doorways as a result of I hate the individuals outdoors,” Aguero informed me. “I lock the doorways as a result of I really like the individuals inside.”
Aguero’s on-line persona is intimidating. However once I met him, he struck me as shy. He averted eye contact and spoke with a shaky voice and a frontero accent. He had agreed to permit me to shadow him for a few hours for a Vice Information story. He picked me up at a fuel station in El Paso. After I opened the door, I noticed {that a} buddy of his, a former Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent, was sitting within the again. We’d be occurring one of many surveillance runs Aguero makes alongside the border to get footage for his social-media channels.
“I reside and breathe the border,” Aguero informed me. “It makes it exhausting to also have a relationship and even friendships at occasions, as a result of I’m simply so obsessively, compulsively devoted to this.”
As we drove, he informed me concerning the evolution of his political opinions. As a younger man, he had studied for a real-estate license. Whereas in school, he’d volunteered with Democratic Consultant Beto O’Rourke, a fellow El Paso native. In the future in school, Aguero’s professor challenged him to articulate why he was serving to Beto. “I didn’t have a solution,” he informed me. His professor responded with a proverb: “Lifeless fish flow.” Aguero remembers this because the second when he started questioning his loyalty to Democrats. He give up working for O’Rourke and ultimately discovered a house in conservativism, and a selected curiosity in immigration points.
In 2019, the Southern Poverty Regulation Middle flagged Aguero’s connections to the United Constitutional Patriots, a now-defunct militia group that might detain migrant households alongside the New Mexico border, at occasions holding them at gunpoint earlier than turning them over to legislation enforcement. Aguero would usually patrol and submit movies with UCP members, and infrequently recognized himself because the group’s spokesperson.
In 2020, Aguero ran as a Republican to signify Beto’s former district, which incorporates most of El Paso and its suburbs. He misplaced the first—by loads. He informed me that his politics don’t match the normal GOP framework both. Aguero blames Democrats and Republicans for the nation’s immigration disaster. Each events, Aguero believes, deceive the general public, saying they “work collectively to manage the plenty.”
Driving within the automotive, Aguero informed me that whereas he’s patrolling distant places, the very first thing he appears for are footprints, discarded garments, plastic water bottles, and different trash. We ultimately received out of the automotive and adopted a path of footprints that led us into underground tunnels that smugglers and immigrants use to cover from Border Patrol brokers on the U.S. aspect of the border. We ultimately got here throughout piles of T-shirts, sweet wrappers, backpacks, and electrolyte water, all left by immigrants who had shed their belongings as they struggled to outlive the desert warmth. (A Swiss NGO counted greater than 700 migrants who died or went lacking whereas making an attempt to cross the U.S.-Mexico border in 2021, making it the world’s most deadly land crossing.)
We additionally discovered belts and shoelaces strewn throughout the bottom, indicating Border Patrol apprehensions. When undocumented immigrants are caught, brokers usually have them take away their laces and belts—objects which can be deemed harmful as a result of they can be utilized as weapons or to commit suicide—earlier than escorting them to detention facilities.
Regardless of Aguero’s vigilance, we didn’t run into any immigrants that day. However he assured me that, earlier than he picked me up, he had noticed somebody he thought was undocumented, and tailed him round El Paso, recording him till Border Patrol officers arrived. “They made the apprehension,” he informed me proudly in between sips of an vitality drink.
Many individuals would empathize with these making this crossing, however Aguero doesn’t. He usually criticizes mainstream information shops for portraying asylum seekers as susceptible individuals, and was eager to persuade me that the individuals crossing the border—“all males trying like Ninja Turtles”—have been harmful. On-line, I had seen Aguero name immigrants “roaches.” Lots of the younger males he chased had the identical accent as Aguero, the identical shade pores and skin—their ancestors got here from the identical locations. I received the sensation that by searching them, he was distancing himself from them, and from his personal foreignness.
A few months after my encounter with Aguero, in the course of the 2022 midterms, I coated the election in Texas’s Fifteenth Congressional District—an extended drive east from El Paso. The district, a part of which sits alongside the southern border, is greater than 80 % Latino and has historically been a Democratic stronghold. I used to be anticipating voters to rally round Michelle Vallejo, the 33-year-old Latina operating as a progressive Democrat who campaigned round city in blue denims, Tejano boots, and a star-spangled button-down. Throughout her marketing campaign, she stood beside her father, Daniel, acknowledging her humble Mexican roots.
However one other Latina, the conservative Monica De La Cruz, had a story that voters discovered extra interesting. “Persons are upset that whereas they waited their flip to immigrate to america, Democrats are actively ignoring legal guidelines on the books and permitting tens of millions of migrants to come back into our nation illegally,” learn one among her marketing campaign emails to voters. Democrats, it went on, welcome them as a result of “in the event that they’re given sufficient handouts, these migrants will ultimately be Democrat voters.” De La Cruz made historical past by flipping the district pink.
That form of rhetoric shares some components with the“Nice Substitute” idea—the concept of a coordinated effort to interchange white individuals with immigrants and other people of shade. Eric Ward, a senior fellow on the Southern Poverty Regulation Middle and an professional on authoritarianism, informed me, “It’s used to justify this concept that we aren’t coping with an immigration disaster, however we’re in an existential battle for the preservation of white America.”
De La Cruz’s victory stunned me, nevertheless it shouldn’t have. I’ve come throughout many different Latinos who, though not as militant as Aguero, are beginning to harbor comparable anti-immigrant emotions. After I was in El Paso, I spent a night on the residence of Dolores Chacon, a Mexican immigrant and Trump supporter who lives in a humble residence overlooking the border wall. I had by no means seen a home so bodily near the border—just some toes. Chacon had put up what she known as a “freedom fence” to safe her property from immigrants. From her yard, I may hear the rumbles of Ciudad Juárez and, every so often, the screech of an American Border Patrol automotive engaged in a high-speed chase.
That evening, Chacon and I hosted a roundtable dialogue for Vice Information on immigration in her residence with about 10 different Latinos. They have been academics, entrepreneurs, and native politicians; young and old; light- and dark-skinned; naturalized residents and American-born; lifelong Republicans and up to date converts. Most of them have been the descendants of immigrants.
“We have now to name the issues what they’re … They’re criminals as a result of they’re breaking the legislation,” Irene Armendariz Jackson, a grandmother who’s now operating for Congress, known as out. “I’m speaking about pedophiles. I’m speaking about murderers. I’m speaking about rapists.”
“Why doesn’t Nancy Pelosi let all of them into her home?!” Jennifer Ivey, a farmer whose mom is from Mexico Metropolis, yelled.
“Now that now we have that monkey virus. Now we’re gonna should get one other vaccine!” Chacon stated, laughing, referring to Black Haitian immigrants on the border. (The World Well being Group has renamed monkeypox “mpox,” as a result of the unique virus identify performs into “racist and stigmatizing language.”)
Probably the most telling a part of our dialog was when the group began speaking about American tradition and identification. Milcha Bermudez, who had the strongest Spanish accent within the room and had lived in Mexico for years, saved insisting that her level be heard.
“It’s essential that they assimilate,” she reiterated, sporting a pink MAGA hat.
“Once you say that immigrants ought to assimilate, what does it appear like to ‘be an American’?” I requested the group.
“This can be a free nation. We have now a sure way of life right here,” Bermudez stated.
Armendariz Jackson added that “individuals come into the nation with their tradition” and may not perceive “there’s an American tradition, and a part of the American tradition and traditions are our legal guidelines, our flag.”
Our legal guidelines, our flag. Analysis means that opposition to immigration could have much less to do with financial anxieties about jobs and wages than it does with cultural identification. Jens Hainmueller, a professor at Stanford, and Daniel Hopkins, who teaches on the College of Pennsylvania, reviewed greater than 100 research about attitudes towards immigration from greater than two dozen international locations. The pair concluded that nativism is rooted in a worry that newcomers will distort nationwide identification and corrode cultural norms. Natives, Hainmueller and Hopkins famous, don’t care that a lot concerning the race and ethnicity of immigrants so long as they be taught the language.
The extra Latinos migrate to america, the extra they’ve struggled to show themselves as “actual People.” A 2021 research investigated how white individuals’s attitudes towards Mexican and Black People shifted from 1970 to 2010. In locations that skilled greater ranges of Mexican immigration, white individuals grew extra hostile towards Mexicans and hotter towards Black individuals. The findings counsel that xenophobia towards Latinos runs so deep, it might probably subdue even this nation’s most pernicious type of prejudice: anti-Blackness.
If assimilation is what Latinos search—and, in fact, a lot of them do—then their embrace of nativism ought to come as no shock. The political scientist Benjamin R. Knoll started predicting within the early 2000s that this might occur. Knoll, who on the time was a graduate scholar on the College of Iowa, remembers a lady scoffing on the notion that Latinos could possibly be nativists as he offered an early model of his dissertation, about immigration attitudes, at a political-science convention in Chicago. Knoll concluded that as Latinos continued to assimilate into American society, their pro-immigration bias would slowly dissipate, and “maybe ultimately disappear altogether.”
The hunt to suit into American society is driving some Latinos towards excessive nativism; in spite of everything, nothing is extra nationalistic than making immigrants, a sworn enemy of many white People, your enemy as nicely.
Towards the top of the day I spent driving round El Paso with Aguero, I broached a topic that had been on my thoughts for a lot of hours. Aguero, who continuously referred to immigrants as “illegals,” has a legal file himself.
In 2003 and once more in 2004, he was arrested for possession of marijuana. (The fees have been later dropped, however he was convicted for possession of drug paraphernalia.) In 2010, he was sentenced to 2 years of probation for assaulting a lady, having punched her within the face after she refused a kiss. He didn’t adjust to the probation necessities, so he was sentenced to 3 days in jail in 2012. And in 2015, he pleaded responsible to a third-degree felony after getting in a automotive crash whereas driving intoxicated, critically injuring a passenger in his automotive. I discussed to him that I knew of those convictions, and requested: “Ought to I be extra frightened of migrants than, say, somebody such as you?”
“Effectively, I’m an American citizen. I’m not out right here breaking into different international locations,” he stated. “These persons are in America!”
Aguero spends as many as 9 hours a day alone in his automotive, scanning the desert. He is aware of individuals assume it’s bizarre, he stated: They inform him so. “I journey with the music off a whole lot of the time.”
“And what do you concentrate on?” I requested.
“Simply all the things,” he responded.
However I used to be positive it should get lonely on the market, surveilling the border—searching shadows of himself.
This essay has been tailored from Paola Ramos’s new guide, Defectors: The Rise of the Latino Far Proper and What It Means for America.
Once you purchase a guide utilizing a hyperlink on this web page, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.
