“Ukrainians don’t care who might be president of the US,” my boss, the editor in chief of one of many largest tv stations in Ukraine, informed me in 2012 as I headed abroad to cowl the American election. I used to be on the Obama marketing campaign’s headquarters, in Chicago, when the president gave his victory speech that yr—however again then, Ukrainian tv didn’t broadcast reside at night time, so my report didn’t air till the following morning, native time.
Overlaying the 2024 U.S. election for the Ukrainian media was a wholly completely different expertise. Folks in Ukraine have been following each flip. A number of Ukrainian radio stations referred to as me for experiences from the rallies I’d attended in Saginaw, Michigan, and State Faculty, Pennsylvania. Ukraine is at warfare, and the US is its greatest supplier of army support; the way forward for that relationship was at stake. The competition’s eventual winner, Donald Trump, had promised to finish the warfare in 24 hours—which Ukrainians understood to imply that he meant to promote our nation out to Russia.
However for me, that was just one dimension of this election’s significance. I’ve lined 5 American presidential contests for the Ukrainian press, beginning in 2008, and in that point, I really feel that I’ve witnessed an American transformation that resonates uncomfortably with the Ukrainian previous.
After Ukraine grew to become unbiased, in 1991, our political events have been for many years run from the pockets of oligarchs. A handful of unimaginably rich males, every with holdings in media and business, managed factions of political representatives who competed virtually solely with each other. Political campaigns lacked substance and consisted primarily of non-public assaults. In the US in 2008 and 2012, against this, the candidates had actual constituencies and precise debates about well being care and the economic system. Many Ukrainians envied the energy of American establishments, media, and civic engagement.
Positive, I used to be a bit shocked when, at a 2008 John McCain rally in Columbus, Ohio, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger warned voters that socialism was on the rise and would destroy America the way in which it had his native Austria. I had simply been to Youngstown, Ohio, the place I’d interviewed laid-off staff who lacked primary well being care; Austria, in the meantime, was a rustic I knew nicely, and it had one of many highest requirements of dwelling on this planet. Why would an elected official peddle such nonsense to this monumental crowd? Nonetheless, American democracy appeared, to an outsider, like the image of well being.
The roles had all however reversed after I got here again in 2016. Ukrainians had risen up in 2014 in opposition to the corrupt, Russia-backed authorities of then-President Viktor Yanukovych. Our transition wasn’t excellent, however we elected a authorities that was eventually severe about reform. The Kremlin responded by occupying Crimea and assaulting japanese Ukraine, the place it backed separatists within the Donbas area. A low-level warfare would proceed within the Donbas straight up till Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, in 2022. Even so, we have been build up our democracy. One thing was occurring to America that appeared to level in a unique path.
That yr, People have been extra divided than I’d ever seen them. And it wasn’t straightforward to speak with Republicans. Some Trump supporters informed me {that a} European reporter may by no means perceive their views on weapons. One shut the door in my face at a marketing campaign headquarters in Asheville, North Carolina, explaining that he didn’t belief the international media. I’d reported from the rallies of pro-Russian separatists in Crimea and the Donbas, who thought-about Kyiv-based journalists suspicious if not outright enemies, and I knew when to depart.
That feeling wasn’t the one disconcertingly acquainted one. The worldviews of many People I talked with that yr diverged starkly from the seen info of their lives. Democrats scoffed that no person would vote for Trump—however the pleasure at his rallies was plainly evident. A person at a Trump rally in Wilmington, Ohio, complained to me about unemployment. Neither he nor anyone in his household had misplaced a job—actually, the mayor of Wilmington informed me that the city had greater than 300 job vacancies. A retired prosecutor informed me that the one media outlet he trusted was WikiLeaks. I used to be reminded of Russia’s coordinated disinformation marketing campaign in opposition to Ukrainians: Because the begin of the warfare, we’d been flooded with fabricated information. We had struggled to make the worldwide press perceive that high-profile politicians have been merely inventing tales. Now one thing comparable appeared to be occurring in the US.
As of this fall, Ukraine is 2 and a half years into an all-out warfare with Russia, and America is eight years into a mode of politics that my American colleagues describe as substanceless. I listened for mentions of Ukraine on the rallies I attended, and heard none. The closest the candidates got here was when Trump, in Pennsylvania, promised that his administration wouldn’t become involved within the affairs of “international locations you’ve by no means heard of,” and Kamala Harris reminded a crowd in Ann Arbor, Michigan, that Trump had a wierd fascination with Russia. Nonetheless, the Trump supporters I spoke with assured me that their candidate would deliver an finish to all wars, together with the one in Ukraine. I heard this from Invoice Bazzi, the mayor of Dearborn Heights, Michigan. And I heard it from rally-goers, together with an aged girl at a J. D. Vance occasion in Saginaw, who informed me that she’d persuaded skeptical relations to miss Trump’s persona and concentrate on his management qualities and skill to deliver peace to the world.
Harris didn’t communicate a lot about international coverage on the occasion I attended in Ann Arbor, however she did warn her viewers in regards to the threat of fascism. That phrase shocked me. Because the full-scale invasion of our nation, Ukrainians have regularly used it to explain the Kremlin of Vladimir Putin. The worldwide media have been reluctant to choose up the time period, maybe as a result of it’s so closely freighted with historic that means. However now it has change into a part of the American political vernacular.
This American marketing campaign season was rife with reminders of a politics that have been as soon as routine in Ukraine, and that we are actually completely happy to be largely rid of. We all know very nicely, from our expertise, what occurs when billionaires personal media platforms: They’ll withdraw endorsements written by their editorial boards and again political candidates with a view to curry favor. In Warren, Michigan, I talked with a person who claimed that he’d earned $80,000 in a single month for accumulating signatures for Elon Musk’s petition to assist the Structure. In one other echo, the Trump camp threatened that it might problem the election outcomes in the event that they didn’t identify him the winner: Ukraine has some expertise with elections adopted by months of litigation.
A number of the People I met on the marketing campaign path wished to know if I discovered the state of affairs of their nation disturbing. Positive. However all the things is relative. People are lucky to not reside via what we do in Ukraine. There have been instances prior to now week after I’d be reporting within the Midwest and, due to the time distinction, the air-raid-alert app on my cellphone would go off in the midst of the day, asserting one other nighttime assault on my dwelling metropolis of Kyiv. In between interviews, I’d scroll via photographs of the buildings hit, hoping to not see my household’s dwelling.
Trump has received the competition for the U.S. presidency. If he withholds army support, Ukraine might undergo big losses on the battlefield and large civilian casualties. However a method or one other, Kyiv goes to must work together with his administration. My time reporting on the marketing campaign has satisfied me that this election was not an aberration a lot as a actuality to be accepted. For the foreseeable future, the US will flip inward, turning into a rustic increasingly more targeted on itself. Outsiders will merely must take this into consideration.
As for the specter of encroaching authoritarianism, I stay an optimist. Take it from a member of the era of Ukrainians who efficiently defended democracy: To seize a state requires not only a sturdy chief however an apathetic society. Democracy survives when residents actively defend their rights on each degree.
I noticed a variety of that in Nevada and Arizona, the place I spent the final two days of the marketing campaign following canvassers. I went door-to-door with members of the Culinary Union of Las Vegas—a guest-room attendant, a cocktail server, and a porter—and listened as they urged residents to concentrate to the Nevada Senate race. In Phoenix, I adopted a gaggle of volunteers from California who’d spent weeks making an attempt to speak with folks they disagreed with. They informed me that they had knocked on 500,000 doorways in Arizona. Pals in New York and Washington informed me that they or their family members had finished marketing campaign work outdoors their cities—writing letters, phone-banking. Even these essential of each candidates and the system itself cared deeply in regards to the nation; some who have been alienated from the nationwide races targeted their energies on native ones. I’ve by no means seen something like this in Europe, the place elections are all about going to the polls as soon as each few years.
One factor now we have realized in Ukraine, confronted with international invasion and warfare, is that life goes on. The identical might be true for America after November 5. I’m reminded of the time a international journalist requested a Ukrainian normal how Ukraine would survive the winter. He confidently replied that after the winter, there could be spring.
