This text accommodates references to sexual violence.
How do you clear up an issue like Andrew Tate? And will ‘optimistic masculinity’ influencers have the reply? It is a complicated query — however with Worldwide Males’s Day upon us at this time, it is one we must always definitely face head-on.
Regardless of being charged with rape and human trafficking (which he denies), Tate has a persuasive sway over boys and younger males, with analysis exhibiting that one in three younger males have a optimistic view of him.
His profession trajectory – from Large Brother and TikTok notoriety to imprisonment and right-wing conspiracy theories – has triggered risky debates about masculinity: Is it inherently poisonous? Do boys must be taught not to sexually harass their feminine classmates? Ought to feminists – as Caitlin Moran explores in her newest ebook What About Males? – be turning their consideration to males?
Whereas a lot has been written in regards to the rise of influencers selling “poisonous” masculinity – outlined within the Oxford Dictionary as “a set of attitudes and methods of behaving stereotypically related to or anticipated of males, considered having a destructive affect on males and on society as a complete” – there are male influencers who use their platforms to advertise a moderately completely different message: that masculinity can (and sometimes is) optimistic.
However do they really stand an opportunity towards their “poisonous” counterparts? GLAMOUR spoke to the Managing Director of Past Equality, a charity selling optimistic masculinity, and Dr Alex George, a content material creator, creator, and UK Ambassador for Psychological Well being, to study extra.
The influencer economic system trades in human consideration. Influencers compete towards each other to safe consideration earlier than promoting it to the very best bidder. And the eye of boys and younger males is an more and more profitable product, as high-earning content material creators, together with KSI (value $27 million), Logan Paul ($45 million), and Mr Beast ($500 million), have came upon.
However, as all of the above have realized, producing controversy is a quick observe to reaping consideration (and due to this fact £££) from social media. Unsurprisingly, producing controversy often includes offensive or inappropriate behaviour. Simply take a look at Mizzy, the 18-year-old former TikToker who went viral for all of the mistaken causes after filming himself abducting an aged lady’s canine, coming into different folks’s homes with out their consent, and strolling as much as younger folks at night time and asking in the event that they “wish to die.” As Mizzy informed Piers Morgan: “Hate brings likes, hate brings views.”
Enter the algorithm. In 2022, an investigation discovered that TikTok bombards younger males with misogynistic content material (usually that includes Andrew Tate) after watching male-oriented movies, together with clips of canine, males speaking about psychological well being, and comedy. As Dan Guinness tells GLAMOUR:
“What’s going to begin out as watching a YouTube video in regards to the struggles that males are dealing with of their lives and methods to cope with these struggles – very respectable issues that they should cope with – will [lead to] a video that explains these struggles as an assault on males.”
The Crowther Centre in Australia outlines that optimistic masculinity is outlined as: “The expression of attitudes and behaviours (character strengths and virtues which any gender might need) which were embodied and enacted by males for the widespread good, each individually and for the group”
